?

Log in

No account? Create an account
Utterances Acquaintances Calendar About jonnynexus.com That Way That Way This Way This Way
Critical Miss Has Been Cited In An Academic Paper! - Planet Jonny
jonnynexus
jonnynexus
Critical Miss Has Been Cited In An Academic Paper!
No really!

I was just browsing through the editorial of the latest issue of Places To Go, People To Be, and one of the articles looked quite interesting:
Our second piece is an academic paper from Dr David Waldron. This may seem a strange development for what is mostly a hedonistic occupation but D&D is now 30 years old. Many roleplayers have children, or even grandchildren, and roleplaying is a much more common term in people's vocabulary, particularly with reference to computer games. As public awareness of the hobby has increased, as the games have come of age, so has intellectual interest in the game grown.

David's paper is entitled "Role-Playing Games and the Christian Right, Community Formation in Response to a Moral Panic" and was presented at the December 2003 Tasa conference at the University of New England, Armidale. He is keen to hear from anyone who would like to comment on his article and I think it would be very interesting to hear from anyone personally affected by the clash of Christian and Roleplaying cultures.
So I started skimming through the article, and what do I find? The following gem:
Another tactic was a process called church baiting in which gamers would provoke fundamentalist churches into loud raucous displays in the media and in public gatherings and then humiliate them by revealing it to be a fake or leave satirical models or slogans at the gathering place or supposed site of Satanic activity. An example of this approach is an extract from an article in "Critical Miss" an online Gaming magazine, on how to provoke a public response from fundamentalist Christians. [...] The following is an example of church baiting taken from an article in "Critical Miss" magazine.
And he then proceeds to quote a few choice sections from a jokey article I wrote about how the best thing that ever happened to roleplaying was when the fundamentalists convinced everyone that it was a cool, dangerous, risky activity to be engaged in, the worse thing was when they stopped, and how we might persuade them to start again.

And we get a real honest academic footnote too!

I don't think I've ever been quoted in an academic paper before.
3 thoughts or Leave a thought
Comments
From: bastun_ie Date: August 26th, 2004 05:34 am (UTC) (Link)
Er... congratulations?
From: (Anonymous) Date: August 26th, 2004 06:47 am (UTC) (Link)
I'm not sure what's more frightening... that Critical Miss is being mentioned in a serious academic article, or that someone might be suggesting that Critical Miss is fulfilling an important and meaningful public function for society by exposing hypocrisy and knuckle-dragging ignorance in overzealous fundamentalist twits.

Critical Miss being heralded as a champion for public understanding and acceptance... that's kinda like Penthouse being recognized for promoting women's rights. You brits are just crazy.

(Makes me wish another issue was in the works. There's got to be another article or so in "Church Baiting", but then again, you could say it's already been done with _Kill Puppies For Satan_.)

Darrin Bright
From: (Anonymous) Date: August 26th, 2004 08:42 am (UTC) (Link)
Im so proud!

Bogboy
:>
3 thoughts or Leave a thought